Where To Eat
Dining During the Holidays
Cape May is known for its vibrant food scene, and the holidays bring an extra touch of magic to dining out. From cozy inns serving traditional holiday favorites to fine-dining restaurants with seasonal menus, you’ll find something for every taste and occasion.
Many restaurants decorate beautifully for the season, adding to the festive charm—twinkling lights, garlands, and candlelit tables make dining out part of the holiday experience. Whether you’re looking for a romantic dinner, a casual lunch between shopping trips, or a celebratory family meal, Cape May’s dining scene has plenty to offer.Cape May’s culinary scene shines even brighter during the holiday season.
Important Note About Hours
Not every restaurant is open daily in November and December. Many operate on reduced winter schedules, close on certain weekdays, or take short breaks around Thanksgiving and after New Year’s. Please check current hours and make reservations in advance to avoid disappointment.
Plan Ahead
Holiday dining in Cape May is popular! Book early, confirm hours directly with the restaurant, and consider weekday lunches or early seatings for more availability. However you celebrate, savor the season—one delicious bite at a time.
Casual Dining
The Lobster House
Location: 906 Schellengers Landing Rd., Cape May
A Cape May landmark offering indoor dining, a raw bar, and dockside drinks aboard the Schooner American.
“It brings me back to the Jersey Shore I grew up with—authentic, unpretentious, and wonderfully stuck in time.” Tripadvisor, June 2025
Ocean View Restaurant
Location: 235 Beach Ave, Cape May
Old-school diner now serving breakfast and lunch weekends only.
C-View Inn
Location: 1380 Washington St., Cape May
No-frills neighborhood bar with cheesesteaks, wings, and local vibes.
George’s Place (Beach Ave)
Location: 301 Beach Ave, Cape May
Greek-American fusion with breakfast favorites, sandwiches, and gyros.
“The chicken gyro was probably the best that I have ever had… the fries… my husband and I couldn’t get enough of them.” Tripadvisor reviewer
Fins Bar & Grille
Location: 142 Decatur St., Cape May
Seafood-centric menu, creative cocktails, and live music on the patio.
“The ahi tuna nachos were amazing, and the live music made for a fun evening!” Yelp reviewer
The Ugly Mug
Location: 426 Washington St., Cape May
Pub-style menu, beer mugs on the ceiling, and lots of Cape May character.
“Fun place with character and tradition — the food was good and the vibe was better.” Yelp reviewer
Delaney’s Irish Pub
Location: 400 Washington St., Cape May
Relaxed Irish-American spot with Guinness on tap and pub favorites.
“Great spot for a Guinness and fish & chips. Friendly staff.” Google reviewer
Cape May Fish Market
Location: 408 Washington St., Cape May
Seafood counter and café inside the Washington Street Mall.
“The crab cake sandwich was loaded with meat — better than expected!” Tripadvisor review
Fine Dining
Washington Inn
Location: 801 Washington St., Cape May
Cape May’s go-to for classic fine dining. Elegant service, seasonal menus, and a deep wine list.
“Head to Washington Inn… order the baked escargot, an herby, buttery, gruyère‑crusted number served with crostini.” The Infatuation
Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant
Location: 1301 Beach Ave, Cape May
Beachfront dining in a historic mansion. Known for its upscale seafood, quiet ambiance, and attentive service.
“The cocktails were perfect, the food, superb! The best sea-bass we’ve ever had.” TripAdvisor, June 2025
The Ebbitt Room
Location: 25 Jackson St., Cape May
Inside the Virginia Hotel. Sleek, modern American cuisine with local ingredients and cozy lighting.
“We visit the Ebbitt Room every year, and it always lives up to our expectations. We absolutely loved our meal—everything was fresh, delicious, and perfectly prepared.” Open Table, August 3, 2025
Union Park Dining Room
Location: 727 Beach Ave, Cape May
Refined dishes with French and American influences in the historic Macomber Hotel. White-tablecloth service with ocean views.
“Our first visit to Union Park. Great atmosphere, delicious food, and wonderful service (a BYOB too!). So glad we discovered this spot. It is now on our Cape May favs list.” Tripadvisor, June 2025
Primal by Mia
Location: 406 Beach Ave, Cape May
Upscale, oceanfront steakhouse and seafood restaurant known for its wood-fired grill, elegant presentations, and sweeping beach views. Perfect for special occasions and romantic evenings.
“Our dinner at Primal was incredible — from the perfectly cooked filet to the attentive service. The ocean view at sunset made it unforgettable.” Tripadvisor reviewer
Vintage BYOB
Location: 1048 Washington St., Cape May
Charming and upscale yet relaxed. Inventive seasonal dishes and a beautiful garden setting. Open weekends.
“Pleasant al fresco dining, excellent dinner… the food was outstanding…” — TripAdvisor
Maison Bleue Bistro
Location: 653 Washington St., Cape May
Stylish and intimate French bistro by the team behind The Hugh B&B. BYOB, creative menu, and elegant ambiance.
“Outstanding food, ambiance, and service… charming atmosphere, especially on the porch.” — OpenTable